Disappointing Celestron NexStar 5SE.
In December 2019, my family bought me a Celestron NexStar 5SE Schmidt-Cassegrain telescope for Christmas. The last telescope I had owned was a 4” aperture, 700mm Greenkat Newtonian, which unfortunately sustained damage to the primary mirror and was therefore discarded.
After several observing sessions with the 5SE, I decided to clean the corrector plate and eyepiece lens. As I started on the corrector plate, I noticed what appeared to be a kind of wheat-grain “husk” or similar, stuck under the plate’s retaining ring at about the front 10 o’clock position. In looking more closely, I discovered that this husk was not in fact outside but actually inside the tube, behind the corrector plate glass next to the plate’s support flange. ( On reflection, this came as no surprise really, as I had only then recently discovered that the telescope was made in China. Like many, I’ve historically had much disappointment with products made there. )
I contacted Celestron UK informing them about this and was surprised to be told that this situation was straightforward enough for me to rectify myself. Since this was a brand new and delicate piece of expensive equipment, I declined to do this, stating that as this was a manufacturing defect, I wanted it sorted under warranty. Afterwards, having received the tube back from Celestron, I noticed that they had in fact sent a new one, i.e., the serial number was different - so perhaps it wasn’t that easy to fix after all !
Then in November of 2020, I found that the “red dot” finder scope was beginning to perform intermittently when the rheostat wheel was turned. I reported this to Celestron who sent me out a replacement. However this one is monstrous by comparison and instead of the red dot, it shows a sort of wide set of red concentric circles which make it very difficult to slew on to the target star. I put up with this one for a while but then, on following an Internet tutorial, I had some success repairing the original. ( It worked for a while but sadly has recently begun failing again. Apparently the rheostat control knob slips past its own stop and this pulls on the wires. )
While I feel that the Go To function is good, I have to say that I have been fairly unimpressed with the over all quality of the imagery with the 5SE. When I think back on using the modest 4” Greenkat, I found that the Andromeda Galaxy core was very easy to see - the Celestron is somewhat indistinct by comparison ; M57, the Lyra ring nebula appeared as a definite smoke-ring shape while the 5SE displays it as a round blob. With M27, the Dumbbell Nebula, the Greenkat offered a view which had 2 distinct dumbbell shaped lobes while the Celestron’s image appears to be more circular. And even with the GoTo function, if the initial Sky Alignment isn’t absolutely spot on then a bit of hunting for the Globular Cluster in Hercules is invariably required.
In other words, a 4” manual telescope which I owned over 30 years ago was in fact superior in clarity to what I have now. And yes, I know - 30 years is a long time eyesight-wise, but mine is pretty good.
If this hadn’t been bought as a gift, I would have changed it some time ago. I couldn’t recommend Celestron products to any prospective purchasers.
P.S. The moon looks quite good, but then it does so through a pair of binoculars.
Date of experience: August 20, 2022